Your ingame name: PPUNCH301 The offender's exact ingame name: CreepyMinnyz A description of what rule they broke/how they broke it: Having Illegal Item Evidence/full screenshots.
This player no longer has that item, apparently it was sold to another player over auction. By just having it in their inventory it doesn't prove that they are the ones to have created it. I am going to close this one as lack of evidence since he no longer has the potion. The owners have been notified about the item and where to find it though.
Thank you for the report. Unfortunately the evidence provided is insufficient. Should you gain more evidence in the future, do not hesitate to report this player(s) again. Kind regards, The Staff