For anyone saying that the current trophy system is fair, it's not at all. It's completely biased towards likeable people with several trophies which are earned though gaining likes.
For every trophy that is earned for getting positives or likes, I want the opposite to that. For example, Someone likes you! You have got your first like! Someone doesn't like you! You have got your first dislike! Etc.
Then we would probably have players purposely putting players down and bringing hate to the community in hopes to get rewarded... No support.
Im kinda neutral. I think it would be good because if you got enough negative, you would get a negative trophy, but it should be not called a trophy but something else. Idrk...
No Support Really, I think this would just encourage people to do bad things to get these trophies, so then they can get some cool name like "Experienced member" or even "Boss Member". It is a good idea, and it would benefit people like you, but I don't think it would promote good deeds towards the server.